|
|
Post by DrTentacles on Jun 20, 2019 18:30:31 GMT -4
You know the drill. How could it be done better, do you prefer having rankings IC or OOC? Give us your best...or worst.
Remember, you can always use a guest account if you want to be anonymous.
|
|
1,884 Posts
0 EP
EXP
Total
18 Years
Female
"x"
Student-Rank Quirk:
U.A Third Year
Played by:
|
Post by Yumi Tasukai on Jun 20, 2019 18:34:12 GMT -4
for a bit of info on the process
Round 1 was collecting nominations, and the amount of nominations you got also added a scoring factor of 'popularity'
round 2 we collected info from you guys to help, but we basically used the 4 other traits to grade too
Personality
Power
Versatility
Teamwork
And popularity from the first round
Using examples found in threads
We had as many staff as we could review as many people as possible in the time frame we worked with and ranked the students based on total scores
|
|
879 Posts
0 EP
EXP
Total
20 Years
female
""Angel of Mercy""
Pro Hero-Rank Quirk:
Angel Wings
Pro Hero
Played by: Jazzy
|
Post by Angel Surami on Jun 20, 2019 18:34:29 GMT -4
I liked the way the votings were done for the most part,but I do believe that there should be some sort of OOC component so that if a character isn't the most social or has a select group of friends that they hang with the most their options for getting votes and getting ranked aren't as limited. I think maybe each person should maybe get 2 votes, one for their characters choice and one for their own choice or something along those lines, yes it's a bit more work but at the same time it gives the wallflower characters who still accomplish big things but just not as frequently a chance to be honored.
|
|
448 Posts
0 EP
EXP
Total
Male
Student-Rank Quirk:
U.A Third Year
Played by:
|
Post by Arthur "Reddarcc" Hunter on Jun 20, 2019 18:44:39 GMT -4
As for round 1, i think it being IC is completely fine. Kinda made it hard for me personally to vote but i think thats a good part of it, makes you think about who to actually vote for instead of just discord buddies.
Round 2 though, should probably be OOC, since im pretty sure a couple people did that after a while, and streamlined a bit. Possibly, grab a couple example threads (For example sports fest) And throw them into the nomination post so its easier to actually look at characters to judge em. I know i didnt say shit in round 2 cause A) I didnt know what exactly to say IC wise and B) which threads to look for that would give me a good idea of the character. you could probably throw some IC flair in there if you wanted, though, could be funny.
|
|
434 Posts
0 EP
EXP
Total
16 Years
Male
Student-Rank Quirk:
|
Post by Shimizu Haruto on Jun 20, 2019 19:50:23 GMT -4
Honestly, the one change I would make would be to reverse the order of the rounds. Give everyone a chance to say, this is why my character deserves to be on this list, before the vote happens. That way people can cherry pick the best examples of why their character deserves more attention, and give it in concise forms so people who have never threaded with them can quickly read through the things their character should have learned about each nominee without having to dig through old threads again. After everyone who wants to nominate themselves has, hold the vote to decide who gets onto the ranking or not.
|
|
